Hell, I feel underappreciated as a writer a lot of the time. Would I qualify?

I think you would qualify - I think your writing is terribly underappreciated. On the other hand, I think there's also a very common reason for it: Once someone sets "Oh my god" into a comment, words often fail to follow, because that's usually such a perfect fit for your stories.

You would fit a one day a week category of appreciation headed "Repeatedly Stunned By."

Chase